Knight-Errant - A Normal Game Mafia Wins!

[Brakuren]

I found myself

[Arctic]

okay so having read achro’s iso, derps is definitely town, for obvious reasons (like, just read it)

the way achro talks about wisp in this post:

@Achromatic

i see town wisp has already picked someone to start a great back and forth with. How wholesome.

is almost always how wolves talk about villagers in an argument together (wisp was arguing with brakuren, so i’m inclined to say it’s a good look for them as well)

@Achromatic

town friends

Wisp/Milli
Rhea
Brak
Sultan
Kiiruma

gn

i think there almost always has to be a wolf in here given that achro doesn’t bus much on fol, and i’m mainly looking at rhea because i townread the rest. there’s also a lot of posts that seem like TMI on sultan being town but knowing he’d want to town his partners i’m a little wary considering him spewed town just for this

ngl this was kinda less useful than i thought because i feel like most of these conclusions already aligned with my reads. but maybe that means my reads are more likely to be correct

achro thinking marluna is SK either means they’re just unaligned or it was a deliberate ploy to seem unaligned
this is a helpful observation i know but i’m just brainstorming lol. it seems he did the same thing on day 1 before the redcheck though so i’m inclined to say it’s just unaligned

[Arctic]

ngl i think the rest of the wolves are probably in the bottom half of the posters (Not because of this, just because I have townreads on the other people for unrelated reasons)

i have no idea how we’re supposed to find SK, and i don’t know if i want to take achro’s claim that mafia killed frost at face value either

[Arctic]

if the SK did kill zug, it’s probably because they either thought he was mafia or because they suspected them

the first thing is because i feel like SK might be inclined to nightkill wolves in this setup, especially if town fucks up during the day

[Marluna]

Sadly I’m just a VT here, so mafia need a rethinking, if they think I’m the SK.

I really want to find the SK as well, and I thought you still could help us out, despite you being scum.
I thought it worth a try, but I guess It wouldn’t make sense changing your narrative at this point so we won’t have conclusion about you being unalligned with other people in this situation.

[SultanOfSlam]

Man yall dont learn do you… pissed at me for pushing a scum read… then yall lynch the same innactive as last game. Come on yall

[Millium]

tbh at some point at EoD, Rhea came in with a post, that felt like drastically different to me, in contrast to early day 1, where we were like basically twins

@Rhea

I also dislike where this game is going. I actively townread Bionic and otterpopd, SultanOfSlam and Crescent are far from my bottom tier, and SirDerpsAlot, while someone I do wolfread to a degree, he has seemed intensely reasonable as of late in a way that makes points I simply don’t see the wolf motivation for.

I would be willing to vote for Someone if others would. I agree that the way they handled the Bionic vote is awkward and wolfy.

this post, pivot to Someone just feels extremely lazy
/shrug

[SultanOfSlam]

@Marluna

Sadly I’m just a VT here, so mafia need a rethinking, if they think I’m the SK.

Why are you openly claiming?

[Millium]

if derps is town, wolves should have just memed on this game honestly

“pissed at me for pushing a scum read” is still reads as dismissive

but ya Someone is just being bullied, I still want to look at why that train exploded

[Millium]

i have thoughts on 2346, but ill wait for Marluna’s response

[Brakuren]

@Millium

if derps is town, wolves should have just memed on this game honestly

“If derps is town”

Are we playing the same game?

[SultanOfSlam]

I mean waant i getting yelled at atleast leafia for pushing Otter. Like whu push a wagon i wasnt beleiving in idk just a bit annoied

[Brakuren]

@SultanOfSlam

mean waant i getting yelled at atleast leafia for pushing Otter.

Leafia pushes otter for not explaining reads and then they don’t explain their own reads

[Millium]

im almost always going to talk this way, unless a person is dead, or their alignment is mod-confirmed

[Marluna]

I thought Achro could help finding the SK, since he is still a good player, even if he is scum.

[SultanOfSlam]

Ehh i get the sentiment but now it gives scum one less person to worry about shooting to get a pr.

[Brakuren]

@Millium

im almost always going to talk this way, unless a person is dead, or their alignment is mod-confirmed

You are constantly casting doubts on town reads?

“Is Derps town after that omega towny EOD” “Idk”

[Marluna]

Honestly.
My mistake.

I changed my mind during writing the post, and I totally forgot I claimed in my first sentence…

[Millium]

i think it was a really townie eod, but like omega towny is just u shading me for the shake of shading me, I dont even think you are able to have a conversation without doing so lmao

[Arctic]

@Rhea

@Achromatic

Also my inclination is that the person starting day 1 and choosing extreme violence is probably not a wolf.

Please, I only get that privilege on sites where I haven’t yet played as wolf. Make an actual read on me.

@Rhea

@Achromatic

Town tend to find me suspicious too.

Ah. I see. We have that in common, then.

there’s no reason this can’t be w/w
but as i’m reading this iso i got to these posts

@Rhea

Understand that my motivation to play this game is not at its highest right now.

I do not have a particularly strong townread on Crescent, but much of the wagon on her feels like it is motivated by policy rather than by a genuine, thoughtful case. If you feel someone is behaving unacceptably and you do not want to play with them, that should be handled through the report button, not through the voting one. I townread or at least townlean everybody on the wagon, but I do not think it is motivated by victory, I think it is motivated by frustration.

I do not think Bionic is a wolf. I think he’s careless town. The way he’s boldly challenged me and other players without backing down is frustrating, but it is not something that ever gets one townread, nor does it actually end up advancing much wolf agenda.

I am hesitant to use meta from games I did not play, but I will say that a glance over Bionic’s posts in Popcorn3 shows a player who struggled to express a single read, even when grilled over it. He was too afraid to express a single opinion. He shows none of that fear here, and it would be a striking gameplay difference between the two games. Again, though, this is not conclusive, and players are capable of improving from game-to-game.

otterpopd is a player who has been plenty towny and the wagon against her is unwarranted. She seems completely unconcerned with projecting town or pushing agenda, and pushes with a genuine curiosity toward the game which is virtually identical to the game we played where she was town (and I N1ed her). She is also a stronger solver who I would like to continue having in the game; to misexecute a town otterpopd would be a waste.

SirDerpsAlot is the only current major wagon I can really see myself supporting by the end of the day. Dec, Frostwolf103, and Someone are other players who I do not feel I have reason to townread, though I currently believe there to be wolves among my townreads who I have not yet sufficiently evaluated.

@Rhea

I also dislike where this game is going. I actively townread Bionic and otterpopd, SultanOfSlam and Crescent are far from my bottom tier, and SirDerpsAlot, while someone I do wolfread to a degree, he has seemed intensely reasonable as of late in a way that makes points I simply don’t see the wolf motivation for.

I would be willing to vote for Someone if others would. I agree that the way they handled the Bionic vote is awkward and wolfy.

and feel like they’re pretty townsided if i’m right on otter/sultan
it’s kinda hard to decipher since i feel like they’ve mostly been townreading villagers but also mostly pushing villagers and the poe is people that i kinda think are just being ignored