Okay
So “Ishmael’s post is fine because she’s a self-aware player” would’ve been a fine argument I’d have been willing to accept if there was like, evidence of that, because I don’t actually have much mental notes of what Ishmael is like as a player
But if you’re going off of vibes we’re going to agree to disagree I think, pretty much its left to what other people think of Ishmael in general to interpret that post
Now maybe the GM predicted that the role would claim D1 and predicted that I would neighborize Ranta and “claim” that and I skill issued by submitting a day action too early
I think i could see the PoV that this is a neutral who wants people to visit them but i am not so confident they just out allignment deciding GA so early.
It puts a big target on your back and if you cant confirm who your “Target” is it kinda just makes it more messy for you in the long run.
Its again why i think its either like a townsfolk or a Visit wanting neut.
It could maybe be a lost wolf trying to signal evil but eh. i am not as confident.
But Gummy is right that my usual calculus on roles like this is “it’s better to reduce variance and just instaflip her”
2 Likes
Which never feels great because voting out a 3P Day 1 is equivalent to not voting at all
1 Like
which is why i am curious why ranta would just insta claim unless there is reasons we don’t know of.
She says instaclaiming neutral is her meta
I am gonna be honest. i have been trying to read this game for the last 4 hours.
but like i have not been in this game enough for me to continue reading lol.
I am so fucking tired
1 Like
I think it’s also possible for ranta to be real
The issue is that scum almost certainly have disruption which means they can go first in action priority
1 Like
i dont think i have seen a neut ranta to confirm this
@diafiasco I think its best to leave ranta alive until d2 and then discuss killing them because if we kill them d2 scum might waste actions n1 on trying to change her alignment
1 Like
I’m just going up the list still sort by post count re-read smallest posters
I’m vetoing any Ishmael vote today my understanding is that she will either 1) have hard mech tomorrow or 2) be anticlaimed tonight because of how much she has claimed
1 Like
Wait she claimed
Oh yeah lol. Fair
apparently yeah.
VOTE: Ranta
Then act like it
I’m bored of the goose wagon now I’m gonna vote someone who has received zero pushes while doing zero things just to vibe check
VOTE: Willow
just a small clarification.
what was the wagon formation you were going for when you voted?
like from what i have seen you were anonygooses’s first vote?