Drakor (@Squirrel2412), you, accompanied by Zelsh (@Leafia) and the older watchman, are able to follow the trail without much difficulty. The footprints were evidently laid quite recently — you’d guess sometime after last night’s thunderstorm — and they stick out easily in the fresh mud.
At first, the trail leads you down the street that the pewter shop was on, which is filled with plenty of people, but as it winds its way through the city, it’s only a few minutes before it cuts through a back alleyway. It’s still no challenge to follow the trail, but unlike the street you were previously on, it seems to be devoid of any other people. The older watchman looks warily at the alleyway, drawing his shortsword as he starts to advance down it.