Secret Palpatine - Completed - Jedi (Whysper, Jarek, Jane, AtNoName, Squirrel, Crichard) Win

Forum Games Completed
,
#1021

but if you want the long answer

I think your reads are fake because I physically cannot get behind the progression. You make one read on Whysper and Squirrel from a reaction test that whysper mentioned in advance, and now they’re suddenly locktown. That doesn’t track.

I think that the excuse of “I’m being annoying to get better reads” is fake as fuuuuuuuuuuck without saying results, and even if you said “oh I didn’t get anything out of it” I’d find that more believable. But right now? It feels like a really cheap cop out.

Also, as for your recent post now, you should know that the point of reaction tests like that is to analyze the results. The fact you posted nothing about them is what’s wack.

#1022

I called him Sith since he fucking came into thread wanting to “Assassinate”

#1023

I have no idea why that itself is wolfy seth

1 Like
#1024

What? Do you not understand my reads? I said Whysper is likely town because of their response to suggestion while Squirrel is likely town because their response to Whysper’s response to my suggestion. I did say it was one of my reasons, the other is simply a lot of mindmelds and agreement which indicate we have the same thought and considering I’m town, Whysper and Squirrel are probably so.

You have failed to realize that I’m still reading you and I’m not gonna let you become interrogater here. I’m here to solve the game idk about you. Like I’m pretty certain that regardless of my answer you would have gotten the same conclusion.

I mean I have posted results. I annoyed Seth enough times and figured out he doesn’t have much awareness to be Sith (or at the very least he hasn’t slipped).

Likewise, my post on Whysper is how it became my reads.

#1025

And… I’m trying to read you. And as you’ve so kindly said yourself, you’re trying to be obnoxious to read for results. Being like this then acting like I’m not trying to solve the game is just… bleurgh. The entire game doesn’t center around you, you know.

No. I think your reads are unfounded.

which was literally mentioned in advance. You’re putting so much stock into it that it feels fake.

Okay. Lots of mindmelds with Squirrel who agreed with you… exactly once on a mech point. And in the case of Whysper, she’s absolutely the type who can be very agreeable, so why do you just not think she could be pocketing you? How are you getting your extreme confidence?

And then proceeded to basically ostracize seth because he annoys you. :thinking:

And you didn’t get a read on Whysper by annoying her???

1 Like
#1026

I know it doesn’t, theres a reason why I’m not forcing people to follow me. Likewise, if I don’t cause disruption and get the ball, then how am I supposed to take the initative and read people?

I think you literally do not understand this. I’m basically the reason why Whysper was thinking about RTing Squirrel because I suggested her to pick someone they find null.

I do not have meta on her and also pocket paranoia is reserved for later.

what? I never find Seth annoying, I find him impossible to convince which is why I read and proceed to ignore him, but I actually can’t this game for mech reasons (aka the logistical nightmare).

I never annoyed Whysper. I simply suggested something which prompted her response which you for some reason don’t understand. Reaction tests stop working once you say it out loud.

#1027

I personally prefer that people not try to annoy Whysper…

3 Likes
#1028

besides, annoyance only works on active people

1 Like
#1029

there are some exception which I generally review on a case by case basis

#1030

Rn a lot of Amelia’s point seems to stems from lacking context. Trying to shade my reads and then be surprised that I have already explained them is an icing on the cake for why I think Amelia is scum.

#1031

Even though I’ve not only acknowledged your explanations but also pointed out that I still say they don’t warrant your level of confidence

Something you’ve decided to ignore

1 Like
#1032

I already told you, I have nothing that warrants suspicion otherwise.

#1033

You have “nothing to warrant suspicion” because none of their other posts are anything to acknowledge

You don’t locktown someone because they post one good post and the rest are fluff

#1034

Did I ever say I locktown people? I simply said they are likely town.

#1035

Saying “Okay you 3, let’s work together to find the last Jedi” heavily implies a locktown status or just generally an extreme confidence in their townness, which I think isn’t warranted

1 Like
#1036

Its not.

#1037

Amogus

#1038

you simply failed to realize that I’m always re-evaling no matter what game i’m in.

I don’t just locktown people and forget reading them for the rest of the game. Otherwise, I would’ve just stopped talking with you and wazza.

#1039

Dude, get off your high horse

You are showing absolutely no evidence of doing this, all I see is you just repeating your explanations that I’ve already stated are poor, and you respond by just calling me a wolf for “acting surprised”

1 Like
#1040

You asked the question, I respond with the answer.

If you think my arguement are poor, then thats on you. It’s not my job to convince you.