Secret Palpatine - Completed - Jedi (Whysper, Jarek, Jane, AtNoName, Squirrel, Crichard) Win

as a spectator who is quite experienced at the game
jedi played very well (especially atno/jane/whysper for being able to towncore and correctly put sith out of government) but sith made a few key blunders + a bit of bad luck that probably cost them the game

  1. minor error - amelia should have elected a jedi as chancellor and not wazza
    the deck was at that point in time 8 S and 3 J, and it’s incredibly unlikely that you pull JJS which is the only reason that you would want a sith chancellor to your sith president
    drops unnecessary shade on wazza for being in a red government that could be shunted onto a jedi chancellor instead
    it also removes from amelia the option of conflicting to take out one of the liberals that will be very dangerous down the line (see pt. 2)
    amelia postured around this a fair amount and atno caught it and i think it wasn’t advantageous to even do that at all
    you only want an s/s government when there’s a high ratio of J/S cards in the deck

  2. major error - wazza should have thrown the j when she had the chance
    in a vacuum this doesn’t look like a terrible idea-- setting up a soft to palpatine that youre a fascist
    but passing the 3rd jedi policy had disastrous consequences for the sith chances of winning
    if you look at the president list, there are 5 vice chairs that will pass jedi policies that come after wazza-- the first of which being atno who has had up until this point amazing social reads handling a deck with an 90% chance of drawing a blue
    in other words, it’s quite likely that after atno’s presidency, she’ll have to deal with 4 non-sith vice chairs on a 4-1 policy track and guaranteed 2 blue policies coming up between them
    silviu is the only sith decently likely to pick chancellor-- if isolde is chancellor before the 3rd red and conflicts, that’s game over
    so it put sith on the massive backfoot for the entire rest of the game

5 Likes

What? We had spectators?

1 Like

i learned that mid-way through the game so

2 Likes

although tbf jedi probably could have made a bunch of key blunders had the game made it into 3 sith territory
its just hard for jedi to blunder very hard before that aside from like, throwing j policies

1 Like

:wowee:

I do gotta wonder why 24 hour phases for everything were decided (which did make the game extremely slow) and then changed by a single post that wasnt even in big text and very hard to miss

it didnt matter too much in the end though

3 Likes

basically yeah
its way easier for inexperienced sith to blunder policy choices + claims in the early game since jedi don’t have any choices on that front
but its also super easy (and have seen this before) for jedi to make stupid chancellor choices in 3 red zone that blundered away the entire game
you just need to get to the 3 red zone first

4 Likes

Well no wonder, nobody added it in the playerlist.

2 Likes

image

here’s spec chat btw

1 Like

gg i was

uhh

which alignment are the bad guys

4 Likes

the katzen

1 Like

gg i was katze

2 Likes

along with that I think the game couldve been hosted a bit better
including how many sith/jedi policies were passed in OP wouldve been good as that can easily be misremembered or forgotten I feel like
the hosts being on and using the host account more than their actual account wouldve been good as well so that you can easily tell what are imporatnt posts that are game related

because these are important posts that people should probably know about but its hard to tell theyre actually important because

not that its not ok to interact with people as host, thats a great thing, but if youre gonna also be doing actual hosting things you should probably do that on the main account so people have better visibility about it (as a spectator to this game I didn’t even know about the autoresolve thing)

3 Likes

yeah thats fair

i just got lazy and we knew it was end of game

Funny thing is I actually thought you were Jedi.

1 Like

Like 100%.
I actually thought AT was Sith with Amelia and I’m surprised on the outcome here because I discarded a Jedi

CRichard lucky enough received the other Jedi

I should probably post the deck

First deck:
Jedi Sith Jedi / Sith Sith Jedi / Sith Sith Sith / Jedi Sith Sith / Jedi Sith Sith / Sith
After reshuffle:
Sith/Jedi/Sith
Sith/Sith/Jedi
Sith/Sith/Sith
Sith/Sith/Sith

2 Likes