The beatings will continue until townplay improves: Part 2 - The Chessening. Mafia wins!

Forum Games Completed
,
#1623

i carried ez gg

2 Likes
#1624

I didn’t read most of the game so no broad comment but I think that pandora was maybe obvious town in F3 because of things that maybe should not have been said but this is from somebody who knows pandora so shrug

3 Likes
#1625

I would have gone carb over pandora but to be 100% honest I was SO CERTAIN it was apennine at f3 before pandoras vote lol

8 Likes
#1626

I think people were definitely reasonably playing the game tho it was genuine engagement with other people and with the game which is always a plus :+1:

4 Likes
#1627

Ditto.

#1628

I was tunneled on pandora ever since ishmael flipped whoops

2 Likes
#1629

I’m never townreading carbon again unless she’s being incredibly suspicious

5 Likes
#1630

carb was so towny ;-;

4 Likes
#1631

Carbon is good at being a glossy smooth package of townyness and I think usually her actual towntells come from the parts that are rough around the edges?

4 Likes
#1632

Didn’t read game though so do not know for sure

1 Like
#1633

Was the monty hall logic actually applicable there?

(Tbh i found it wolfy bc you’re ignoring all social info in favor of using math to push reads)

3 Likes
#1634

It was.

4 Likes
#1635

jason and I brought up that carbon was weirdly townread despite her always being sus as town and towny as mafia + carbon busses her partners as mafia

but then we got hit by the pandora tunnel (I take partial blame for this) and townread everyone remaining in the game as consequence

also our town meta of her was somewhat validated by her being d1 wagon and having strong read/defend of apennine instead of going for the “easy” misexes + childe kill was genuinely so weird

also I totally got fooled by how “spontaneous” her tiebreaking vote was

4 Likes
#1636

this was kind of my logic with the incredibly funny misty vote but that definitely backfired. ishmael had a hand in that according to her so crazy team play

#1637

I disagree if we’re talking about the final day. Other than that and near the EoD 2, I’d agree though.

#1638

Kudos to Leafia for updating the thread OP, title, and category very quickly. :heart:

1 Like
#1639

image
image1200×630 119 KB

i was gonna post this as soon as apennine voted but i missed it

ggs town this was so fun thank you for hard carrying ishmael :pray:

6 Likes
#1640

Her tiebreakkng vote I found to be pretty wolfy since it felt forced to me.

#1641

Thanks. ^_^

1 Like
#1642

I thought they were both very suspicious on the final day which usually happens in a 1v1, so I mostly focused on prior to that.

Carbonated had some suspicious moments in her argument with pandora, but pandora’s vote itself and the posts surrounding it did not read as genuine at all to me.

3 Likes