sorry for stepping away from this game for a hot minute
ok prolly a terrible place to quote but i just wanted to say all of the posting from pandora here feels super genuine so i would move pandora to a favorable slot
this is among the funniest and best drunkposting/speech i’ve seen in my life. sorry this is not game relevant.
hey i had work until very late last night i’m tryin ok
spooky’s line of questioning though feels pretty good here and even if drunk af ishmael comes off as having genuine thoughts to me. not enough to push into a favorable slot but it leans that way
the early votes none of them seemed genuine which is what i was referring to atp in time. of course later on the votes gain more legitimacy and I’m certainly not saying that they’re invalid points I do think whatever they said makes sense but is flawed. not that it’s illegitimate.
Onto other people:
Zone generally has thoughtful posting and honestly the frustration comes off as genuine? Even if the posting is nai (as I wouldn’t know him well enough) it’s still pretty good
Gummy just comes off all over the place so I have no hard opinion on her
Apennine also just sounds genuine so that’s good
Honestly the only poster i’ve had a problem with so far was my aforementioned dislike of a Jaiden vote but I’ll backread once I’m out of work in a few hours and hopefully this can become clearer than what i grabbed on a skim during a meal break.
Regarding my policy: I will still maintain it, but I also noticed that there are no longer any players who meet this criteria, bar maybe one.
As for who I am most confident of of being Town: pandora and childe.
Reasoning / Readslist
Despite the general aggro Today being mostly directed at gummy and carbonated, I feel like gummy is not giving enough posts that would make me think she’s towny.
Ishmael looks good whilst drunk, but I know from experience that “Ishmael playing whilst being inebriated” is an ability she is capable of doing as Mafia. I’ll leave her at nulltown for now and see if that improves as time passes.
You (apennine) oddly sound similar to another player from a recent past game, and tone-wise you are towny. You also do more than exist and be an echo chamber; you actively engage with other players –in particular, me. So, that looks good, but is it alignment indicative? I don’t know you, so while I’d put you as GTH Town, I can’t put you any higher than “slightest townlean” right now.
Frostwolf usually works under a mindset that I cannot fathom, but if he’s Town, then he hunts Mafia damn well. So I’m planning on leaving him alone for D1.
pandora had a rough start, but her 20 minute monologue really sold me she’s Town. If I had to break down why: Her saying sorry when she wasn’t able to come up with any scumreads.
spooky… has been doing stuff, yes. None of which are pinging me, and the content volume is (according to the remnants of my ever-fading memory) enough to call him as GTH Town. However, uh. I have a minor bias against him since I know he plays well as Mafia. So I can’t put him anywhere above nulltown at the moment.
Mistyx… NGL, I should probably pay more attention to her, because my memory says her vibes are chill, but being chill is NAI. (And I have forgotten what else she has done thus far.)
childe has complied with my request to make a GTH readslist and that post alone is enough to put him next to -if not, then above- pandora.
Jaiden… is a fun-seeker from what I have seen thus far. She is… not producing enough content for me to read. I am trying to get more content out of her, but until I see more, my vote will remain parked on her.
carbonated– I saw people paying attention to her. Some were meme’ing, while Frost is actively voting her. But also: IDK what Frost is saying, and I don’t have any opinions on carbonated beyond “she exists and she plays the game”. She’s just null to me.
Has gummy and Frost as suspects for individual reasons. She not voting gummy, because find unlikely that it’d give more results than voting Frost.
…slightest townlean. It’s literally “better than nothing”, and that’s about it. Nothing out of the ordinary, but also no interactions beyond [Zone, childe, spooky, gummy, Frost]. One might argue she has interacted or attempted to interact with Jaiden and carbonated, but like: This has either gone nowhere or has yet to go anywhere.
Thanks!! I notice both you and Misty are townreading childe. Is that read coming from experience with it? If you can help me understand a bit more, I’m probably willing to follow along with the read.
i don’t remember playing with it off the top of my head (possible i have and it blended in with one of the like 5 other one word starting with c names we have)
more just the way it approached the whole gth readslist thing felt towny to me
