The beatings will continue until townplay improves: Part 4 - The Crestening (Night Two - 8/11)

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

VOTE: Frostwolf103

@Frostwolf103 its over

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

No one cares about t3rm if theyre mafia its probably with a shitposter or frost

Losing a mafia partner d1 in this format seems like death setentence id just insta concede lol

[tutuu]

I dont think its that bad for mafia to lose a partner d1 (in this setup specifcially as opposed to in general), 9v2 is pretty balanced across multiple communities. I think most of our setups here are wolfsided which is why a balanced setup sticks out in comparison and seems townsided

[tutuu]

17:29 for my pizza so i dont forget. Ok im here now

[tutuu]

Which one do you think is performative / newbmaf - zone, or the townreads zone is receiving?

[tutuu]

@T3RMINATOR

you’re overwording things and making unnecessarily long streams of consciousness

Nvm u answered already

Is this really newbmafia behavior in your experience? Im surprised because i have the opposite opinion and experienced with beginner wolf players

[tutuu]

Excellent read and yes Zone is IC

[tutuu]

@soweli

Second point… I don’t know what you’re getting at. Of the 13 posts made, they were all difficult to engage with, which is atypical and thus made me think a wolf was posting.

I was curious / confused, because you seem to be equating “difficult to respond to” with “difficult to post in the thread” and i dont, if im unable or unwilling to respond to something id just proactively post something that i feel like

[tutuu]

I cant differentiate between “ok so pigeon’s town (a joke)” versus “ok so pigeon’s town (im confident)”, they say the same thing, and i cant know your experience with pigeon. And looks like you got your desire to receive a reaction :P

[tutuu]

But yes noted, ill remove him from TRs

[tutuu]

I cant read your mind and i can only question the words that you say re: you saying that im poking at playstyle gaps

[Crest]

T3RMINATOR (3): soweli, Zone_Q11, pandora
soweli (1): Leafia
Hippopablompoyeetus (1): thepigeonnyc
AngryFrog (1): Divergent
Frostwolf103 (1): Hippopablompoyeetus

Not Voting (4): AngryFrog, T3RMINATOR, Frostwolf103, tutuu

[tutuu]

Simple generic “im town btw” opener is slightly >rand towny in my experience, and i find myself naturally / subconsciously doing it as town more often. When i dont know what to say and I dont feel like saying anything but i feel obligated to at least contribute

[tutuu]

Did you cut off a word at the end there? Im not understanding

[tutuu]

I havent explained my push on you at all, though, i havent stated any reason why i suspect you. I just asked you questions. Youre calling it senseless entirely out of towny entitlement, because youre looking at the wrong result, because you assume a villager being pushed = senseless. There is no visible process to criticize in the first place, as in, you cant read my mind

[tutuu]

Probably slightly towny? If im being charitable?

[tutuu]

VOTE: Leafia

Im suspecting Leafia’s newer posts tonally, feels a bit off to me. I feel like she’s very reactionary to what’s happening in the thread (walking back on her Zone suspicion after multiple ppl TR Zone, joining me in suspecting soweli after townreading her earlier, the thing around AngryFrog seems like she’s on the defensive side / backfoot. This:

@Leafia

You don’t know me very good do you? I’m no good at that kind of stuff. Why are you so focused on me anyway?

The beatings will continue until townplay improves: Part 4 - The Crestening (Day One - 11/11)

No it’s not normal for villagers to do so when they’re not under any pressure right at the beginning of the game. It feels performative. Villagers should show that they’re town, not tell. Giving a readslist is easy. Having one with explainations is a bit tougher.

---

The interaction with Frog seems off to me, could be both wolves

[tutuu]

@Leafia

What’s there to elaborate on?

This too

[tutuu]

@thepigeonnyc

I genuinely think it’s not impossible for the mafia team to be Hippo and Frost lol
I feel like T3rminator is certainly on a team but I can’t decide which

Weird use of “genuinely” here if wolf, it would be a double lie (the post itself, and then an extra lie on top (genuinely))

Feels more like a villager who is self-conscious that his read might be discarded by others because its the two lowest posters. Reads like this are often discarded

If pigeon if wolf I think he writes this exact same post but omits the word “genuinely”, there is just no point. Rare for wolves to go out of their way for this ime

[tutuu]

I might be overthinking it!