can we make everyone post a readslist at some point today
maybe I haven’t been keeping good track, but I feel like I have no clue who the poe of half the game is besides their most preferred vote or something
1 Like
Where do you currently stand on reads?
1 Like
shending has a very confident townread on jason, did you have any thoughts on that? [intended to be non-aggressive here]
Its been a very long time since i both found a mafia and convinced town to hang them so i really wouldn’t put much stock into what im saying tbh
1 Like
Yeah i dont like most of shendings reads lol
2 Likes
Theyve just had a few suoer towny posts imo
1 Like
I thought snow was clear off willow spew, but maybe i’m reading incorrectly there. What are your reasons there?
don't read if you're hippo
Skimmed snow’s responses to willow bc i hadn’t looked at that side of the interaction and yeah these look genuine and not like awkward w/w theatre
1 Like
Maybe ill have to reread
Youre right in that if willow claims bg then snow goes over instead of willow, wolves are in a bad spot as willows bg claim wont last forever
1 Like
I am putting on my biggest ever jason blindspot glasses and ignoring every wolfy macro he’s done to say it all feels in-line with town jason mindset (I think it would take either an outright redcheck or gummy saying jason is sus to make me seriously doubt this)
I really feel like gummy has to be town, but the fact that I don’t have any poe I have conviction in is scaring me slightly. nevertheless, I am hoping her d3 posting will hardpocket me
you sound fine and are mechanically like super unlikely. keep assertive-posting please, it reassures me
you could say that everyone outside of this is my poe: hippo, chomps, frost, shending, barwe, snow
I think I am in agreement generally that hippo and frost are town after all, maybe frost more than hippo? frost is cagey in a way that pings more town to me than not (?)
snow is a tossup in that I’ve liked their responses, but I feel their absence
chomps feels towny, and I have lost my desire to personally vote him, but I don’t think I’d shield too hard or push back against a chomps wagon
this leaves shending and barwe. I think it would be really wild if that was exactly the team, so I am maybe leaning one wolf in there? however, I have no clue who it would be, and they both have good reasons to be townread
shending has been around more. he has good positioning on willow’s wagon & his reads are very detailed and feel thought-out. he is the other major jason-townreader in this game, I think. he did start writing up his jasoncase at a time when jason and ishmael were tied 3-3, so if jason is town, shending did seem to put some major resources into towncasing him. I am a little paranoid it was a pocketing attempt, but also, not very necessary, necessarily. shending also started scumreading hippo. it should be noted that both his towncase on jason and wolfcase on hippo felt very similar to thoughts I had (albeit articulated more deeply and better) – and I don’t know if I should read it as mindmeldy that we had the same thoughts/pings or scared that he just took some of the floating thoughts in the thread and used TMI to elaborate on them. one thing that makes me very hesitant is whoever pointed out that shending kept getting willow’s name wrong which unpaired them…
barwe has incredibly good tone I think. very chaotic, sounds genuinely excited at his solving, hasn’t done anything particularly wolfy or towny? I think we may have given him too much credit for the wallpost, but it is like, towny. and I do still like his opener being to defend shending. I may have to reread his readslist at some point to remember what he said about ishmael (too funny to be wolf?). I don’t think I have a real tinfoil on him besides a fear that shending/barwe isn’t pure
1 Like
Yes i can play d3 m
2 Likes
Whose
2 Likes
I knew that would get your attention…
well frost is voting for you at the moment. I think shending and/or brawe mentioned you as well you could iso them :)
2 Likes
That aint several m
1 Like
Also is there a reason ash didnt bg dia
Wasnt that their last message d2
well it could be more, I have no idea where chomps and snow are at right now
1 Like
well chomps is at brawe
1 Like
I posted my reads at eod yesterday, and haven’t reevaluated since. Will do tomorrow
2 Likes
unclear
dia hypothesized d2 that ash saved them instead of ybw n1 though (does consec rule even exist in this setup, zone let me consec target when I was bodyguard in his game)