30000th poster gets a cookie (cookie thread (Part 7)) (Part 10)

which is weird but it seems to be the case?

1 Like

Id feel hesitant to as well, in general i dont do it unprompted, but in this case it was really frustrating to me because she insisted i do it, she was also serious and ambitious about it, she wanted to monetize it eventually, or monetize being an author in general. I didnt wanna lie to her that i enjoyed her latest chapter

1 Like

lose lose situation

2 Likes

She is capable of growing more resilient just like we all are but at that moment she didn’t have the emotional resilience yeah

1 Like

Amphoreus moment (surprised you didn’t run into Cerydra/Hysilens).

3 Likes

cerydra/hysilens is held back by 3.5 sucking

4 Likes

I will fight anyone who defends it

2 Likes

‘oh but cool reveal at the end’ that’s precisely the problem

2 Likes

Fear (I liked it a lot, but I also have a high tolerance for bad pacing).

1 Like

if they sliced off 1/3rd of the stuff from 3.7 and gave it to 3.5 then both patches would be much better received

3 Likes

I do think purple prose in an Appeal To As Many People Possible game is a bold choice, so maybe not lol

1 Like

From a zoomed-out perspective, I like how 3.5 is structured.

The pitch of, “The thing is one cycle away from actualizing, and Lygus will do anything in his power to stop you,” is an excellent narrative throughline in the same way that I liked how 3.0 gradually built up the complexity of its Nikador fights.

The problem is that it nixes both its “vying for Cerydra’s favor” and its “only one cycle to do this” plotlines far too early, and I feel like it doesn’t give the thousand-year war against Lygus enough time to really sink in impact-wise. It also means that it ends up pushing all the Cerydra/Hysilens stuff to the Styxia section, which sinks (ha) the pacing hard.
Good things-wise, I really like the tribute scene, and I love that they hid Frozen Tides until that section, and I think they found a clever way to beat Lygus. I also think I came in expecting Hysilens to be a stopgap and was surprised how much I cared for her story afterwards.

1 Like

yeah, but constructive feedback (even if it’s negative) is very different than an insult.

And I still stand by, if someone can’t take a (friendly) negative feedback, they wouldn’t be a succesful (or a happy) author. The first thing you will find you against the most as an author are the critics (and unlike a friend you ask for a feedback, they won’t be nice to you.)

Also probably to fanfic authors (with established characters) this is more likely to happen. (I don’t really write fanfics or know anyone, who writes fanfics, so I don’t know about this, tbh.)

1 Like

I sorta find that people view criticism and insults very similarly
In theory there’s a difference but it’s the tone that matters the most really

3 Likes

It did have hype moments and aura, so I’m actually wrong it’s the best patch in history

2 Likes

A lot of Shaoji’s writing has, “I started writing and kept writing and at some point stopped and realized that I wrote ten pages,” syndrome.
Bro needs an editor.

3 Likes

truth nuke

1 Like

I have embraced limbus and its ‘Actually Getting to the Point in a reasonable amount of time’ storytelling

4 Likes

yo im jaiden

1 Like

hi jaiden

what did you think of imaginal disk

1 Like