BotF I.I - Hand of Darkness - Good wins

Forum Games Completed
,
#2361

What’s the point of Shark being a Minion and lying about Lunatic though?

Wouldn’t it be better if he kept pretending to be Choirboy and cause mild confusion?

2 Likes
#2362

if I was minion here I’d be Boomdandy in that case (at least from what I can tell) trying to actively be executed for no reason

#2363

In that case, oscar goes to me bruddah

#2364

i think that pivoting to lunatic as a relatively important minion (i.e. the scarlet woman or the cerenovus) could make sense given that they just got caught in a choirboy double/tripleclaim and being pinned as evil by the noble and wants to buy a few more days over simply being executed d1 for being 1. socially a bit off 2. in a noble ping w 2 more trusted players 3. in a double/tripleclaim

i think a boomdandy would just let that happen

#2365

yeah but we’re about to execute them

#2366

/shrug
idk
bottom line is tho that i dont think theyre actual demon, altho i dont think executing them does that much harm so like
nyeh
decisions hard

#2367

Well either they’re the real demon who got suckered into thinking they’re not or they’re not the real demon and still worth killing anyway just to be completely 100 percent safe

1 Like
#2368

The inconsistencies you’ve listed and him answering decently makes it feel like he is the Demon/Lunatic.

#2369

You know considering the triple choirboy claim and the fact they are very evil-looking

#2370

he’s either lying about seeing no king, or kiiruma is puzzledrunk.

#2371

There is actually 2 things bothering me about this

  1. If Leafia is a Minion they’d be framing him with the Noble info and considering how quickly Leafia outted her info I’m gonna assume she didn’t plan it out?
  2. Choirboy bluffs
#2372

What?

#2373

Wazza commited french revolution on Kiiruma

#2374

I would really like the real choirboy to out so we can clear this up considering they are now presumed to be useless due to the king being dead.

#2375

Ofc that’s if you choose to believe one of the few people that hasn’t spoken yet isn’t the king who just hasn’t been here in which case whatever

#2376

Kiiruma knows who the real choirboy is.

So we know there is 1 in play apparently

1 Like
#2377

I have 3 claimed choir people.
I don’t think me being King is questionable.
IDK what me being puzzledrunk would do

#2378

The problem is, people read me as good before this, the only reason why I was getting pushed was because of the Noble and the eventual double claim, if I was evil I’d still claim Choirboy to get the others executed right? I knew either I’d be pardoned eventually since people were advocating for it, or I get executed, but I went to lunatic because I legitimately started to believe I was it because of how many people jumped on me and ofc, the Noble + 2 other Choirboys made me think it aswell, I could either take a 50/50 and let others be executed afterwards or just claim Lunatic (which I knew I’d get executed by it) and ruin my demons safety net claim, it doesn’t feel like that situation in my POV would be very smart for a minion either way

#2379

So long as we know that I’m cool with it

#2380

if sharklifter were the actual fang gu, he would have seen kiiruma as the king on the first night unless kiiruma was drunk
so if he is the demon then he’s probably lying about the king thing?
idk nyeh
head hurt