BotF I.I - Hand of Darkness - Good wins

Forum Games Completed
,
#2381

Well if you trust Kiiruma (which you should by the way), then you can be assured that there’s a Choirboi in play

#2382

I would think you’d want to give the lunatic the kings name just to maintain the demon ability as closely as possible. I’ve heard it’s possible to give the lunatic a fake lunatic themselves but that’s strongly discouraged because it puts power in the ST’s hands

#2383

Not telling the lunatic there’s a king in play and then having a king out (and not be a named minion) is like, a massive hint that you’re a lunatic.

1 Like
#2384

Well I didn’t, I believed Kiiruma was something else and was cere’d for a while, so meh I’m not really sure

1 Like
#2385

Well either the king was drunk or the ST decided to give you a helping hand on figuring out you were the lunatic

#2386

If you ask me I think the king is drunk because it’s just too obvious that you didn’t get told who the king was when you think you’re the demon. Like REALLY obvious if you know how it works.

#2387

I guess the second option would of made sense? But tbh it just made it harder because I thought it confirmed one of my minions as Cerenovus or Kiiruma is completely something else and is just bs’ing to get claims easier while dead

#2388

So Puzzlemaster you think should logically guess Kiiruma then?

#2389

Cero on the king wouldn’t make you not see the king

#2390

Cero someone INTO the king, not cero the king itself

#2391

That’s what I thought, and can still be entirely possible

#2392

As a Demon with a potential Lunatic you got to read the entire possibilites instead of being stupid :wowee:

#2393

I mean it could work but with a choirboy in the game there HAS to be a king somewhere, you didn’t get told ANYBODY was the king.

2 Likes
#2394

that raises a second question though for me to be fully satisfied with it
why claim choirboy when you know there’s no king in play?

1 Like
#2395

Like I said, relying on a minion or the Cerenovus to back up my claim as Choirboy would be legitimate.

1 Like
#2396

Probably hoping that the fact there was no king in play wouldn’t be outed until later I would assume

#2397

Nobody can counter claim King, so it logically makes them look good and eventually will make me look good

1 Like
#2398

Then I can completely bullshit about someone being demon once I kill them

#2399

May I just ask you this.
Say I am lying… what are the 3 choirboy claims?

#2400

I got told as one of my bluffs was Choirboy, that’s why I genuinely believed it was a Cere