BotF I.I - Hand of Darkness - Good wins

But there are 2 recorded chambermaid claims and night has claimed chambermaid and snitch so I don’t know on both. Maybe they can clear the air if they get back

Y’know, after reviewing what I just said…
If Whysper’s evil and lied about Leafia not waking up at N2, then it is hypothetically possible for Arctic to be evil.

@Arctic, you better get night to out her role if you want to prove your innocence.

/execute Arctic
@Host_Account_3

I don’t know what I did to make you think arctic is now evil but godamn am I lost right now.

So we got 2 chambermaid claims that much is obvious and we’ve boiled down the evils to a few people.

I’d love a detailed update later but for now I think that’ll do me?

She rescinded indeed. Except I don’t recall her giving us any actual reason to not immediately out her role back then.

It’s basically a paranoia I have.

  • Arctic was obviously Politician given D1.
  • I know Intensify isn’t the Demon because of how confused he was while we were whispering, which implies that Shark is the Demon.
  • The game isn’t over yet, so there has to be a Scarlet Woman who took over Shark’s role as the Demon.
  • Pay attention: What I am about to say is my paranoia. I don’t have any evidence to back this up. This is just a gut feeling.
  • Leafia died N2.
  • Wazza, in attempt to confuse me even further when she thought I thought I was Marionette, claims that Lycan killed Leafia which prevented any other kills from happening.
  • Intensify and I agree that Wazza was bs’ing.
  • Now, how did Leafia die? Lycan claims are obviously fake given the fact that Wazza claimed there is a Lycan in the game, which leaves me with two options:
  1. Some random SW Fang Gu thought it was a good idea to kill Leafia, the Noble claim.
  2. Leafia lied about being Noble when she was SW Fang Gu, and turned Arctic from Politician to the new Fang Gu.

Hmmm? Night retracted the snitch claim.

I’ve mentioned that

Yeah as I thought.

Arctic argued that Whysper’s Chambermaid results imply that -unless she is malfunctioning because of Puzzlemaster- Leafia didn’t wake up at N2, implying that Leafia isn’t SW Fang Gu.

However in that case, WTF is nightingale? She is obviously town / outsider given the fact that Wazza shot her, but I don’t recall us getting any actual info about her role.

That’s a good question. I have Night as a blank on my grim.

If night’s good, then Whysper’s evil.
Given the fact that Whysper somehow thought it was a good idea to withhold information, and the fact that night was shot by Wazza…

I mean, it’s not impossible for Arctic to be good, but again: I have trust issues.

I mean

Whypser’s alignment is bound to Atlas most of the time, since he’s 100% the number 1 jump target.

I think a world where leafia is the Fang gu (from SW) is definitely a possibility considering a lycan claimed they were going to attack them and to make themselves look good they would kill themselves and maintain the lie.

Idk otherwise, Haven’t thought about it enough to write meaningful useful sentences.

*assuming night is still claiming Chambermaid

no night retracted it

I had them as snitch for whatever reason - I’ve seen them claim chambermaid, but other peoples’ chat logs (namely, whypsers) imply that THEY are the chambermaid, so I have no real idea.

:man_shrugging:

night was like “here’s my results” then whysper comes out with extremely similar results and night said they were just spreading word to the people or something

Really? I thought it would be obviously Arctic given the D1 clusterfuck.

Ya, that was D1 Intensify who thought he was evil when he is actually Lunatic. Ignore that.

Okay… so again: WTF is nightingale?

Hiiiii everyone.