BotF I.I - Hand of Darkness - Good wins

Hello. How are you?
Would you like to join in our lovely conversation about what is happening in this game?

id tell you if I knew

Yes, he thought he was evil but the point was that he was a lycan claim. the demon would have known he was lying and also who he really picked to attack. Leafia doesn’t make sense to kill even if they’re maintaining the lycan lie simply because they are so useless to kill and confirm the “lunatic”'s claim a little too well. I do see leafia being a jump as a very real possibility.

Still no idea. I assume good because psycho lol but for all I know the psycho thought night was the magician and killed them lol

I would if I knew what was happening.

Can I get a TL:DR?

I mean… what’s the point of jumping Politician per say when Puzzlemaster is a much more juicier target

I think Night is Fisherman

What are the odds that the fang gu randomly attacked richard or some other talkative, non-obvious outsider and accidentally jumped do you think?

She did this post and it kind of just got lost in the mix

so did wazza

Yes, but we already know Wazza’s role

Yeah that would explain the ST consult.

im saying anyone can fake that

very low

Eh… IDK about that. I believe we have differing tastes. You say Puzzlemaster is juicy, but who in their right mind would ever nominate and vote execute on the Politician claim?
(Hint: Not me. I am not in my right mind.)

But better than 0. Plus if richard really is the snitch - he was talkative D1 and was making themselves seem like a good useful town role, there’s non-zero odds an evil saw that and decided to go for them and got a nasty suprise. Just a thought.

Well yes, agreed. But nothing came of it and she hasn’t tried to claim it yet. So I just think it’s possible that’s her role. Also, she included that in her 3f3.

Though for now I say we pursue the obvious leads that we have instead of guessing on people we don’t know are evil or not - But if there’s a chambermaid I definitely wouldn’t mind it if you checked that tonight ;)

And it’s one of the only remaining roles that makes sense for her

Thing is if the Fang Gu jumped last night, I would be one of the last people they’d think I was an outsider.