COMBELINTORICS MAFIA -- DAY 2

[Badeline]

To be clear, we should be going for wolves now. Trying to hit another 0/3 is ineffective at this point.

[tutuu]

VOTE: Arctic
VOTE: Tommy
VOTE: Ash

[autumnseas]

i think going for wolves is fine

i still feel ok abt freckles but my reasons to tr eaves were at best questionable so i can see that being a wolf

[Badeline]

Do you believe freckles is still town?

If we’re scumreading the freckles voters, its coming from the assumption that freckles is wolf. If freckles is also town, then freckles being such a close wagon doesn’t actually matter. I’m curious to hear your thoughts.

[bystander]

@bystander

*** Ash: bystander frost freckles**

• autumnseas: bystander freckles eaves
  *** Badeline: bystander tutuu frost**
  *** iamagummybear: bystander tutuu frost**
• Chomps: frost
• eaves: tutuu freckles
• Arctic: bystander tutuu freckles
• freckles: bystander freckles eaves
• Tommy: bystander freckles autumn

removed us 3 bolder ones that voted us

[bystander]

bruh

[bystander]

wtf is dat

[Badeline]

Ash voted you, frost, and freckles. He excluded tutuu. I’m not necessarily against townreading him because he still got 2/3, but I wasn’t sure if you noticed or not.

[tutuu]

Freckles could be wolf or could be town getting framed by wolves. I dont have a hard stance yet

[Badeline]

If we assume freckles is a town getting framed by wolves, that means wolves fully accepted a 0/3 beam yesterday, even though thats one of the worst case scenarios for wolves. It would also imply wolves had a lot more control over the wagons than I realistically think they did.

[Arctic]

VOTE: freckles
VOTE: Tommy
VOTE: Ash

[Badeline]

This is more like it!

[Arctic]

this is going about as well as it possibly could for us

i am aiming to vote wolves today

i will defer to the ICs at the end of the day if they agree on the same group of 3, but only if they agree

[autumnseas]

hmm feel like this viewpoint is a bit. discongruent? that’s not a word lol. but wolves accepting a 0/3 i think implies they Didn’t have control over the wagons and id want to look closer at people with less “threadpull”

mm. im sorta getting the freckles thing now tho

[bystander]

i mean if u assume at least 1 wolf here
Ash
Badeline
iamagummybear

obv at least 1 wolf here
autumnseas - idk but suspect a bit more now
Chomps - i don’t think its chomps imo, his vote put the 0/3 over freckles iirc
eaves - nonchalant dgaf queen
Arctic - i think pushed for autumn early ? idk lol he also suggested himself tho so like wolves wouldn’t want 2/3 ofc
freckles - most likely a wolf or else no wolf was tried to be voted for the 1/3 (besides eaves arctic early kind of, freckles was the only viable one later on)
Tommy - i forgor

if freckles is town i feel like it’s possible 2/3 of the first group is mafia, just decided to pull the cred ig? idk im confuse

[bystander]

oh

[bystander]

mb LOL

[Frostwolf103]

@Badeline

Frostwolf is still about the same. Bystander is someone I’m unsure on, and ai think as I read the rest of thread I’l have a stronger opinion. I’m realtiming right now, because I want to, but I still have yet to read posts #200-400.

@Badeline

@Frostwolf103

One, I do not like how Chomps starts the game and initially how Arctic played along calling Chomps untrustworthy

I didnt ask you to explain your reads. Please explain why shooting for 2/3 is mechanically more optimal than shooting for 0/3.

@Badeline

The more I see frostwolf being anti0/3 consistently I believe it might be t!frostwolf

I remember later in the game, while I was realtiming, Frost was still very adamant on this while still voting the same people. So, it also feels like it isn’t being done for the purpose of pushing agenda.

@Badeline

really liked tutuu’s recent answers to my questions, the pushback screams v thought patterns to me. I’ve also liked frost’s attempts to go 2/3. Bystander has been voted by everyone, and has posted a lot, so while I don’t have many personal reasons to v read her I also don’t have any reasons to think she’s wolf. I’d find it more likely there’s something I’m missing.

VOTE: tutuu
VOTE: frostwolf
VOTE: bys

@Badeline

Maybe part of my reasons for not feeling comfortable townreading the others who were voted, such as eaves freckles and arctic, is the intimidation factor. Though, I’m unsure if I’ve played with eaves or feckles before, so I don’t know why I feel intimidated?

@Badeline

I’m still don’t really see the Ash wolfread, I remember not minding his posts and I skimmed his ISO and I’ve already read literally all of his posts. Could someone explain it to me?

@Badeline

Do you think his unwillingness to go with town is wolfy though? I see it as towny.

@Chomps

i haven’t noticed that

Suppose I have couple of questions:

What are you talking about me being the same, if you are fine in following the consensus (me, Bys, 22) then what is this about Eaves, Freckles and Arctic being left out when you could push for narrative and beam them instead, and finally is there a reason you need to spoonfeed Chomps about my anti 0/3 stance?

[Badeline]

I believe that wolves did not have control over the wagons otherwise the wagons would not have ended up the way they did. Again, a 0/3 is bad for wolves, so I don’t think they would just let it happen.

[Arctic]

if freckles is town (as the 4th highest voted wagon) then the game should be easy as wolves had basically no influence. i don’t think that’s likely which is why we should vote for freckles today, but it’s useful to know regardless

i think eaves could be a wolf instead of freckles, they are a diff check in my mind but putting a diff check in the same vote isn’t helpful. still think ash is a wolf. tommy is a pretty non-committal guess from me, but it does fit