Haggle (rule discovery game) Round 5.

Did i get the wrong rule

image
Round 5 hand 1

I flip this 180 degrees

Ah the main text can be read as if the card was traded it wins otherwise it loses nvm

Ill out an rule
Rule 5
A) horizontal lines both rules happen vertical lines only one of them needs to or will happen

image

This card exists

İn order for there to be a horizontal line there needs to be two rules but besides the lines its only enlarged

Theres an specific rule for enlarged and black suits then

Now that i read it its basically you lose if you get this card

2-3 no invalids

Ill also trade an green 1 if you want with whatever card you want

Well whatever it was, you just lost my trust.

Eyy. Now we both have handwritten 5s!

…so not just green numbered cards? Or did you completely misread the meaning to begin with?

…sigh. Fine. I’ll trust you again.
…wait. If this is 5, then what is 6?
Is it in tandem with 3?

I’ll throw you a bone: Wrong lines.
(Rule 2 might have a part in this…)

IDK about black suits, but FWIW enlarged cards do not mention their numbers during summaries.

…?

Yee it should be invalid since a tie doesnt exist

I did its the exact opposite of what i said

Considered the divider lines but these are horizontal and vertical lines aswell in the context of this card

There was no invalid hands in this round since you have 2 wins

Say… have we ever confirmed a rule that says: “You win if your number (or its sum) is greater than your opponent’s”?

Maybe all these wins and losses are caused by other rules, while competing for “the biggest number” actually does nothing.

Welp, I am not going to rule-check that one until I rule-check Rule 5.

Yeah, but the meanings (of those lines, in comparison to the dividers) are too ambiguous.
Still… if what you say (about Rule 5; not the green rule) is true, then…

Round 5, Hand 2:

Round 5 hand 3
image

35 vs 36 in that case

Ill force a loss next hand

I recommend you do the same with any green cards you have so we can determine the hand 2 35 vs 36

This was 1-1