Secret Palpatine - Completed - Jedi (Whysper, Jarek, Jane, AtNoName, Squirrel, Crichard) Win

Forum Games Completed
,
#961

From a social read. If Amelia is a Sith, they would be more likely Palpatine as it would make sense for them to pass a Jedi policy the first time they’re in government, then as VC ditch a blue in a world where it’s actually 2 Sith and 1 Jedi policy to force a Sith policy through. Palpatine would usually do all they can to avoid conflicts so that they have a chance to be chancellor with 3 Sith policies on the board.

Mind you this is in a world were Sith!Amelia was actually given a choice and decided to pass a Jedi policy to look better on cards.

#962

In that world, though, Jane would have been Sith/Palpatine and gave Amelia a choice. But Jane claims Amelia had no choice and only had Jedi policies.

#963

Jane can be a suspect for ditching a Jedi policy, if the number of Jedi policies is less than 5.
If there are 5-6 Jedi policies claimed, then it’s more likely that Amelia was forced to play a blue which makes Jane less likely to be a Sith who ditched a Jedi policy.

#964

I mean, I could see a world where Jane is Palpatine and actually did give Amelia a choice to determine their alignment. Though I guess that depends on who claimed first, Jane or Amelia? If Amelia claimed first, then this could be the case and Jane just confirmed. Otherwise if Jane had claimed first, then no, it probably was true that Jane only passed Jedi policies.

#965

Okay, Jane claimed first

#966

yea, thats a bit of gambit that could backfire early on.

#967

Yeah, very true

#968

also detecting the vc is a lot harder since you can’t tell if they ditch a blue or red. This applies pre-reshuffle since there will be 2 card left when the reshuffle happens.

1 Like
#969

So really, I think Amelia mostly likely did get 2 Jedi policies, so basically that whole part tells us nothing about their alignment. And I doubt Jane got 3 Jedi policies, no reason they’d lie about that, so everything about that first government is probably true.

#970

After seeing this palpatine list I am now convinced you’re both evil and at least one of you are palpatine because anyone humoring the idea that I am palpatine is evil and is trying to paint the picture I am palpatine early on so that when the shot comes through later they can use this as an excuse to take it and call it scumreading

#971

That’s not how clearing works…

#972

That’s how it works in my world, there’s no reason that I’m palpatine, so I’m not

#973

I checked and Jane did claim 1st. Which does make the world in which Jane actually gave Amelia a choice is less likely. Depending on if Jane is new to the game or not, it would be more likely for a newbie in Jane’s position to force a Jedi policy as the possibility of losing 2 blues from passing a red is too much of a risk.

#974

I’m pretty sure Jane did say this was their 1st time playing

#975

I can see right through these lies and I know exactly what is going on

#976

To me you are basically the only null in the game. I could see you being any of the 3.

Amelia I see as either Sith or Palpatine.

Jane as either Jedi or Palpatine.

#977

Then your best bet is shooting amelia because if they flip jedi then jane is a jedi, and if they flip sith then avoid making jane chancellor

#978

Yes, definitely. I would advocate for shooting Amelia 1st.

#979

The downside of being the president with the invest check

#980

Is this a good time to mention that there are no flips in this game?