VOTE: Frostwolf103
I think the focus on playing with a similar approach to how he played as town in a previous game feels too forced. It’s also unclear to me how he arrived at the POE in the first place, and how he later ended up seeing them as proven town. The read evolutions feel arbitrary to me.
I don’t townread childe and would be open to considering some pressure on it as well.
I… definitely need some more brain cells. sorry i meant the general progression
what previous game are you referring to if i can ask?
@Mistyx I still haven’t figured out how to quote multiple posts or link them, but if you look at Frost’s posts you should be able to see where he talks about it. Here’s one.
I haven’t read it but I believe he’s referring to the previous game in this series. My concern is it feels like here he’s providing a structure and a formula for himself to follow, while the ways his reads evolve through that don’t make sense to me.
…I can convey this message in many ways, but the point is: I will not let those who don’t contribute live.
I need to ISO Jaiden and myself to remember what made me think she has given content, but I clearly remember her still not having a readslist despite my multiple requests and indifference towards the fluidity of her reads.
The Cheesening. Literally this game’s predecessor.
you catch more flies with honey than with vinegar
i understand your frustration (i was not happy after the gummy flip but that’s something to get into after the game) but like
as a policy i consider any push where the basis of “if you’re town you deserve this” applies to be a bad one
[Partial quote]
Mobile: Press on a word you want to quote to highlight it. Then, adjust the range of the things you want to quote. Then click "Quote.
PC: Click and drag the area of text you wish to quote. Then click "Quote.
[Full quote]
So you know how there’s a toolbar whenever you want to write a post? If you don’t see it, then try clicking the three horizontal lines to the top right of the [???] (not sure how to describe the textbox interface).
If you click reply on a post, and then the most-left button on the toolbar, then you’ll get the full quote of the post you’re replying to. (If you’re not replying to anyone before you click it, then you’ll get the full quote of the OP instead.)
[Pros and cons]
Full quote if responding to wallpost, otherwise partial quote is much faster.
Partial quote only carries over plain text and images with minimal modifications: If you quote a colored and/or underlined text, then expect them to be lost in the partial quote.
Full quote doesn’t have this problem since it quotes the entire post, but you’d have to remove the parts you don’t need, which might be tedious.
Click on the post number of the post you wish to link. A pop-up should appear, with a convenient copy button to the right of the link.
the way i’m seeing it right now is that it seems like he has a formula for how he approaches games and he’s been applying that similarly here as to how he did in part 1
i think there’s some differences and i do wonder whether those are alignment related or just gamestate related
but since his d1 play in part 1 was good enough to get him n1’d that game it makes sense that he’d intentionally try to repeat it here regardless of alignment
Look, I know that my decision is morally grey at best, but the point of this game is to improve townplay, and I cannot do so if everyone keeps letting The Cheesening happen again by letting [those whose townplay needs to be improved (whether it be genuine or fake)] live until endgame. They need to be rooted out early on!
no i get that its just like
im trying to put myself in jaiden’s shoes here
and i feel like town jaiden is not going to improve at all from “you aren’t trying die”
so theres not much improvement to be done on that end
For the record, this is euphemism.
I realize in hindsight that one might argue that these people should live instead so they can learn the most, but I would immediately disagree with such thoughts. These people need to be beat (i.e., punished by execution) until their townplay improve.
everyone is morally grey here it comes free with your role pm
let’s try putting some of this theory into practice
how much weight do you put into the following:
I have already given her multiple opportunities to make a readslist –something even childe could do. I cannot see a townplay in anyone who cannot make reads. Arguments such as “this read will not represent my future read, so I won’t make one now” is balderdash, because as I have said before:
The dead are dead to me. gummy was executed with the least amount of knowledge; her reads mean nothing to me. As for spooky, you said it yourself:
Which is funny, because I am currently not seeing spooky as someone with a lot of thread presence despite clearly remembering he had the most posts at D1. (It must be my poor memory acting up.)
I mainly remember my read of him saying I could not trust him, given that he knows damn well how to deepwolf.
mm
i can’t really argue with this it just seems like a lose/lose situation fmpov
just seems like you’re setting yourself up for frustration as reasonable as the reasons for that frustration are
i have achieved mafia nirvana there is no difference between being bad at the game and good at it
Well I haven’t reached that stage, and neither has tutuu when they started “The beatings will continue until townplay improves”.