how do we feel about ishmael
VOTE: apennine
gonna be hard to convince me that frost push wasnt agenda
Could I try to convince you then on why I think apennine is town
First off out of Frostwolf and apennine if I was forced to pick between the two of them I would honestly say Frost is less towny because of his completely inconsistency, which is something I agree with apennine on (#957)
In post #945 I have literally no problems with any of her reads. I agree with Zone town. I understand the logic for most of t hem (e.g. Ishmael hasnāt left an impression, Frostās reads are unexplained, Jaiden is an āunconfidentā read (#822), etc.) Like when I said Zoneās reads and thought process seems similar to mine then I think he is town. Whereas I think apennine is townmore likely for a similar reason. of course this could be my own bias. but you know. same line of thinking. Apennine also had really good thinking questioning Frost (I like especially #926ish area)
And honestly I think the posts come off as solving the game, but especially early on she feels genuine to me
if i was to pick between the two of them i would say frost is more towny because heās a flipped villager
From yesterdayās perspective. If that wasnāt clear. My apologies. Obviously frost is dead executed town.
If I haaad to pick two people to be town today Iād guess maybe apennine and maaaybe pandora in that order (zone wouldāve been #1 but he is. sadly. dead.)
i appreciate the effort iāll make a post detailing why i disagree later tonight
1 Like
could you go into more detail on this part of the post because it feels like the rest of it boils down to āi agree with herā
I liked how she wasnāt afraid to be a little aggro there to get the answers that she wanted. Maybe itās also general vibes. I thought the line of questioning was towny
maybe im tunneled but i dont see how any of that comes across especially genuine? also like
wolves can also be annoyed if town arent engaging with them i can speak to that myself
ok partial bias hereāI wouldāve had the same questions and wouldāve had the same pent up frustration (sorry Frost) but honestly Mistyx yeah I would like to hear why you think apennine is mafia (you said you would write it up but uh you havenāt yet lol)
hi yeah so
i outlined it earlier in the context of the jaiden push but again penās frost push feels like sheās pushing there because she thinks heās wolfy, not because she thinks heās a wolf
like
i mightāve cherry picked a little here but i think that this is pretty clear evidence of a pattern where pen will consistently engage with frost in a way where she indirectly calls him wolfy
and the actual substance of things she says are wolfy from him and not just unclear or something she doesnāt understand boils down to āheās forcing himself to play like his last town gameā
which i gave a counterargument against that she didnāt acknowledge
VOTE: ap
this entire stretch of posts is. hm. not big on that
opens up the day on the offensive when town is one misexe off lylo
when backing off from it pandora mainly defends why thats a reasonable action for her to take (conditioning from her homesite) rather focusing on why its suspicious which to me reads from a not very towny mindset
evades line of questioning to do with frostwolf with another push on what is arguably lhf
it feels like a pretty large shift in pandoras postings which is what confuses me
pandora still locktown womp womp
Which two players specifically are you referring to here?
the two players who were tied at the end of day yesterday
Hmm, okay, I thought it was strange that you were calling me town. But if youāre ruling out the possibility of childe being paired with me then I suppose that makes sense.
I am not sure what a meaningful distinction between these two things would look like for you. It sounds like you are just taking issue with how I give my reads.