Questions FM - GAME OVER (Mafia Victory)

[Aelin]

elephant?

[JakeTheWolfie]

Could you give something to respond to? Even if I can’t get to that, others might be able to.

[JakeTheWolfie]

[Blizer]

im just thinking kinda based on setup

is it 2 mafia with super powerful abilities or is it 3 mafia with decent power

cause its a 13er, and while it is usually a 10v3 most of the time, there could be exceptions, and i can see this game being one depending on the power of Mafia PR

[Blizer]

ive kinda just been thinking about it a bit tbh

[Blizer]

hell there could be a lost wolf, and we dont even know actually lmao

[JakeTheWolfie]

I don’t see how this could be a fruitful discussion at this time. Maybe later perhaps, but not now.

[Blizer]

yeah fair enough

its just something that ive been thinking about for a bit

[YoubutWorse]

@Blizer

is it 2 mafia with super powerful abilities

the thing for this argument tho is that the mafia wouldn’t know their abilities so itd be way harder to optimally use them, or am I wrong and mafia start knowing their abilities?

afaik everybody has an ability that they dont know so

[JakeTheWolfie]

I’d keep this on the back burner. It doesn’t matter how many scum there are if we can’t find them.

[Blizer]

@YoubutWorse

the thing for this argument tho is that the mafia wouldn’t know their abilities so itd be way harder to optimally use them, or am I wrong and mafia start knowing their abilities?

afaik everybody has an ability that they dont know so

they have to ask the same questions as us

question is how powerful their abilities are tbh

[Blizer]

Yeah thats fine,

it should be tabled for later, i just wanted to bring it up tbh

[JakeTheWolfie]

The OP (as well as my own private role) suggests that the Mafia would not know what their abilities do.

[Aelin]

@JakeTheWolfie

/vote EliThePsycho

I have received irrefutable evidence that Eli is a member of the “Mafia”

@JakeTheWolfie

One hour has passed.

The Mafia are sated.

We must kill them now.

@JakeTheWolfie

Ok this is conftown, doesn’t even know what the mafia is.

@JakeTheWolfie

So, where is everyone? It feels a little aerated in this thread.

@JakeTheWolfie

We should start consolidating votes here.

/vote Hippopablompoyeetus @Sun_Tzu

@JakeTheWolfie

Me, killing the town’s only good player.

overall awkwardness, feels vaguely disjointed from thread

@JakeTheWolfie

I think that if you don’t mind having a little ambiguity, you can figure out your exact role type with only 3 questions.

@JakeTheWolfie

It is complicated, but it is quite elegant.

I’m not saying that you need to follow it, you can ask whatever 4 questions you want. I’m just saying that this is probably the easiest way to narrow down your role type to 1 or 2 options.

@JakeTheWolfie

We are nearing the 200 post mark, which means that the wild flailing about will need to end, and instead normal flailing about will take place, as we actually determine who is or isn’t scum.

@JakeTheWolfie

What is my opinion on Kiiruma/Leafia?

@JakeTheWolfie

Could you elaborate on this a bit?

@JakeTheWolfie

What do you reckon the alignment of the mech-talkers might be?

@JakeTheWolfie

I would argue that, while it is possible for scum to do that, it is not very probable. Keeping such a thing a secret would give the scum a substantial boost above the town.
In this particular case, the information given was also timely, as in it was relephant to the topic at the time. If the scum did choose to reveal it, it must not have been put up to vote, which means that the scum are not as organized as first thought.

@JakeTheWolfie

Sure, anyone could do what I did, and indeed they have tried, however it is up to me to convince and up to you to decide whether it is more likely to come from town than from scum.

Anyone can wagon anyone else, but there are certain wagons that would be highly beneficial for scum to chase, and so more likely that scum would chase them.

@JakeTheWolfie

In short, scum want to say what is possible, the town wants to discuss what is probable.

@JakeTheWolfie

I would like to see more from you, so do please read up on the game and report back with your thoughts.

helpfully unhelpful

@JakeTheWolfie

Do you, in good faith, believe that I would have been able to predict this argument, that I would have been able to predict that someone would have challenged my mech spec as being scummy, as it is mech spec?

i think this quote alone is enough for me to call you scummy af lol, never mind the follow-ups
basically minimizes and then negates the read on you based off of “would i prepare for this lol”… which, one, i dont see why you couldn’t have, and two, it wouldnt have been necessary to prepare, just to be witty and quick

@JakeTheWolfie

Well, yes, that would be the reason why scum!jake would have chosen to reveal his method.
However, the downside to that is that it benefits the town as well, as opposed to keeping it a secret, which would have benefited the scum greatly.

@JakeTheWolfie

Well, if it only wastes the town’s resources, then how would I have been townread from it then?

[JakeTheWolfie]

I’ll respond to this when I get on my laptop, until then all I’ll say is that there are some parts which I agree with you with.

[Aelin]

so you agree youre scum?
For Legal Reasons™, this is A Joke.

[Kiiruma]

Although as people have said… this may be fruitless.
I’m going to say I doubt there’s a lost wolf.
Because I’d think that it’d be a bit easy to guess your ability if you receive a mafia alignment but no scum chat

And this game doesn’t seem to want to make things too easy to guess.

[JakeTheWolfie]

Would you be willing to read any of the other players I mentioned?

[Leafia]

Before I forget…/unvote @Host_Account_1

[Aelin]

uh yeah probably