Need a reason
VOTE: snowe
Sheeping Rue as an act of apology for arguing earlier
legitamately a very good read
iconic
Am I really about to wallpost when I said I don’t like it while posting to people. I guess I really am…I guess this is what happens when you basically miss the first 24 hours. So please bear with me that I’m going to try a silly system that I want to do for fun. Plus it would give a general sense of what my reads are in a POINTS SYSTEM. This is going to be jank.
Summary
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #10 by T3RMINATOR
Honestly as the first post of the game and instant having a post restriction must mean something amazing right? But this could be a thing where it’s just a lie right off the bat to get suspicion off of themselves when there is none of them. To be fair this is a weird game already due to it being overpowered so I don’t know how to truly feel about this. But it doesn’t feel evil sided at the end of the day. +
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #14 by T3RMINATOR
With the conversation that Keisler had with Keisler this post feels like it’s trying to be genuine about the post restriction because it’s a restriction. They want people to know that they are here in this game with a view that they can’t share. I know it’s early on in this wall post but this feels like it’s good. ++
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #18 by Prophylaxis
Like coming into thread with a vote ready I don’t see it being the move a mafia would do getting attention on themselves and someone else off the bat in the shitposting section of the game and this is the section where everything I know is out the window because if I had it my way in most mafia games even numbers on day 1 will be a sleep. But this is an odd number so it may seem more useful to exe today. But it’s an arbitrary vote so this can’t gain points but I don’t know if it’s enough to lose points. =
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #20 by Kelsier
So real but I feel like this is trying to solve the secret of this game. Like the hidden trick and I doubt the mafia would do it out in the open due to the passive of damsel being out there. Like it could easily be framed as later on when trying to make a guess of it it’s hidden. But I doubt that’s the idea of it. But looking for a secret in this game makes me wonder about your role. But that’s all I will say without pushing too much. +
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #23 by T3RMINATOR
I got fucking baited by the post ngl. But like if this is truly fake then it could be a play as the mafia trying to hide with post restriction and come out day 2 if left uncalled out. Then bam it gets seen as a town for the rest of time because of d1 post restriction. -
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #44 by catbae
Me when a bastard game is a bastard game lol. But the way it acted to see a public ability flip seems not genuine. It could just be a case of “org players don’t read” which now when I’m typing is probably true and mafia probs read because they need to know the game state and they probs ping for that to make everyone know that there is a wincon right there to fish for. Plus in the ability it’s probably a town passive or a nuet passive. So either way it’s probably not mafia so they don’t need to worry about it but they probably know to keep an eye out. So here are your half point. /
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #48 by Frostwolf103
A check this quickly into the game. I guess it’s fair to assume that we needed information but this seems like the only information to go off at the moment. But if the other side flips town this should get shot on the spot. +++ or -inf
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #53 by Kelsier
I mean if it works like damsel guesses from botc they probs count everything that isn’t a self force guess. Since if we really wanted to play the best we can just force everyone to self guess. But that’s boring plus this made a guess at someone so this could be just the most hidden plain sight guess and we never look at this. But probs just trying to throw away a guess if it’s evil to earn town cred. So +. (This 2nd part is me rereading so org players don’t read happened to me and this also didn’t read so I’ll leave that here but giving catbae their full point now)
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #63 by Hippopablompoyeetus
Honestly with my deduction of the ability it doesn’t end the game. It just prevents their team from winning but the outcome can change with the team that’s losing making sure that the guesser’s team lose 100% of the time. Which is probably the balance mechanic plus if this is truly real they must have given the person with this passive some busted abilities. =
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #69 by O.kazo
I would probably say this is mafia due to the fact it prevents a lot of things on them if this is real if it came out day 2 or 3. But it came out day 1 trying to get people to not waste their things on them which is a towny play. Sure it could be mafia with this passive or trying to not get stuff on them for reasons that I don’t know. But this seems genuine. ++
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #73 by Hippopablompoyeetus
Based on the announcement it’s probably a mafia ability or the most chaotic neutral. But pointing out how voting dynamics might change due to this could be setting up two things. One explaining how people are going to act different to hide who gets the passive. Or two let mafia get away with sus voting under the guise. But bringing up early seems to be the first thing I stated. +
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #81 by Prophylaxis
This does bring up the point to avoid the mark going on someone that we can just not kill someone day 1. Which could be a valid thing to do [not biased at all wdym]. But honestly noticing this thing is town sided. So take +
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #85 by Rue
I mean yeah if we kill them less bad passives are in play. But with that being a thing they have makes you wonder what other abilities they may have. The thing is, the mafia probably wants to protect the person so it’s worth keeping a note of vote swapping. That is it trying to protect a good ability or trying to make it harder to find the mark. /
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #88 by Hippopablompoyeetus
Another claim of having a bad passive to encourage people not picking them but instead it’s not immunities. Which probably seems more possible then the last post of having tons of immunities. But how do you not know that it’s truly a miller. /
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #96 by Prophylaxis
I said this once earlier but who says this ends the game on the spot. It just causes a loss on the spot getting their team to lose. But since it was allowed, let’s be honest the person who guesses is instant outed and the town can just make sure they lose since everything is out the window. Since there has to be more than just mafia based on the wording of the passive. But ST metaing is towny. +
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #129 by Wazza
I mean not wasting exes is a good thing for us and pushing back on someone trying to kill them off the bat probs mean town. Especially if it belongs to a town ability this gets more points. But we need to aim for the people that we believe are evil to go forward in this game plus a red check claim was made earlier in the day. +
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #140 by tutuu
Honestly based since things can just outright lie. I guess the only thing that can’t lie is exes/night kills. Since thats the base of mafia games so they probs won’t touch that. So this stating this like that probs just makes it town and I did like the logic on it. But one thing of note is that the game is probs solvable with abilities but it’s up to us to find it. ++
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #159 by tutuu
Tuttu talking to Rue both have points tbf. In BOTC you still consider the clearly obvious poison information and try to see why it’s showing it. Since metaing storytellers is probably the only reason BOTC games get solved since it’s reliable and it’s fair game between the story teller and the players. Like I said before, being able to get meta’d as an ST is a symbol of being a good ST since consistency. But Tuttu is also right in a sense that a mech clear is basically impossible due to the fact things can just outright lie to us. So + for both.
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #183 by iamagummybear
Maybe a bit of recency bias due to us being on the mafia team together in FAM. But they did say this quite a bit during the FAM game to get town read and use it to their advantage. So them saying this feels like it’s trying to do the same. -
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #187 by tutuu
Ah shit I’m going to sheep tuttu or something because their posts do seem towny. But honestly I kinda forgot that things can just shrimply just troll. But assuming the post is real atm might be a good way to go due to the fact it helps EOD dynamics and tries to prevent plarity voting and letting mafia run this thread with a minority and not a majority. +
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #227 by Frostwolf103
Well it was a long paragraph of nothing to not explain the vote so I can see where this is coming from. But due to other posts they made based on them saying don’t kill kels and the red check they have more reason to try and think about voting against either of the two. But I still don’t know about this kels thing yet atm but having suspicion on this vote seems reasonable if they truly trust it. +
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #243 by Chomps
Even though they have said nothing this looks like town chomps from other games I have seen of them. For just soul reading and just voting but then goes with logic when it comes down to it. But like this isn’t a hard science so here the half. /
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #246 by catbae
Looks away But based on how people play this game everything needs to be explained at the end of the day. Even if it’s something simple like vibes. Like how I’m vibe reading this post as -.
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #292 by pandora
This seems like the most pandora coded post I have seen. Sure I’m still using filpless as evidence to compared actions with people. But this is very very different from their mafia game in that game. So take your + for free.
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #302 by Rue
I didn’t see those posts as TMI honestly I felt like it was natural imo. But this could just be me being pocketed this early in the game. But I don’t like the way it’s trying to frame this slot. Plus in their next post saying that trying to change their style in some sort of way when it’s clearly NAI imo. Since I want to try and stop wall posting and here I am…wallposting. But declaring a style change just seems NAI. But this is pushing on it so I don’t know exactly the motive behind it but it’s sus. -
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #336 by Prophylaxis
I’m pocketed from this post alone. This seems like it’s great progression and the reads that it has on the board seems very good. So I’m willing to trust this today and probably be a possibly a good person to let have some power in this game. But like this post just scream town vibe. ++
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #399 by Hazardwaste
I’m so cooked as well. =
Odyssey to the Fortress of Lunacy - Day 1 (27/27) - #406 by Altina
I mean if we really want to meta who possibly writes a thing like that is to determine what people enjoy from BOTC outsiders. If we are going to use this as logic it’s someone who likes the damsel hunt and trying to find out their real identity. /
This is where I also realize I have free will and taking a pause halfway through making this wall post because I stopped around post 400. Wanted to check in if somoeone is here to live chat at the very least
Points
| Altina | 0.5 | |
|---|---|---|
| Carbonated | ||
| Catbae | 0 | |
| Chomps | 0.5 | |
| Frost | 4 | -inf |
| Hazard | ||
| Hippo | 1.5 | |
| Gummy | -1 | |
| Jarek | ||
| Kelsier | 2 | |
| May | ||
| Meowl | ||
| O.Ka | 2 | |
| Pandora | 1 | |
| relm | ||
| Ash | ||
| Ruby | ||
| Rue | 0.5 | |
| Snow | ||
| Term | 2 | -inf |
| Tuttu | 4 | |
| Wazza | 1 | |
| Prop | 4 |
Higher points is more trust I give them
1 Like
Thats cute memeking
But not knowing half of the reason based on the vote count I’m kinda shocked that VOTE: T3RMINATOR hasn’t caught more strays after a check happened on them. But I guess it could be something that was manipulated to appear fasley cause bastard. But infos ig
HOLY SHIT SOMEONE IS HERE I HAVE AN EXCUSE TO NOT CONTINUE WRITING MY OTHER HALF OF WALL POST
1 Like
WAIT NO COME BACK
1 Like
Please 
so i can be more informed on certain descision on the future.
1 Like
why did no one react to the “hero” reveal lmao
this is probably evil tbh, in general if flavor sounds good in bastard game = evil and if flavor sounds bad in bastard game = good
my flavor is super duper truper evil
1 Like
That’s something I haven’t gotten too yet. But didn’t you claim a miller so that makes sense that your flavor is “super duper truper evil”
2 Likes
I disagree on your top 3 town i haven’t seen anything towny from them
1 Like
i think its very likely i am a miller because of an elusive pasive which hints at it
1 Like
Still don’t know what this exactly means but I’m going to ingnore it if it’s something super duper important to your role.
1 Like
alot of words
But out of everything I will say at the very least about my role. I think it would be very very very hard to lie to me so I think I’ll trust my rolecard.