Alright, so for this post I’ll do a trustfall. For those unaware, a trustfall is where you take every player and state your best reason(s) for reading them as town. It can help you get out of tunnels and confirmation bias, and if it’s difficult to come up with a reason why a player’s town, that can say a lot. So here goes, in alphabetical order:
Clonedcheese - Has been going after bold targets for scum
Dum - Has been pretty open about their actions last phase
EggYolk - Scum might act more concerned with the growing wagon on them
ElithePsycho - Panic at EoD feels genuine, scum didn’t jump to secure Leafia
Gortia - Doesn’t acquiesce to pressure from active players in a way that scum usually would
Kiiruma - Responses to people look genuine
Sharklifter - Their posts don’t seem to have an agenda
Universal - The tunneliness is a bit excessive for scum
windwardaway - Has been very extraverted in a way that is difficult to maintain as scum
YoubutWorse (previously VooDooSH) - Has done well keeping up with engagement after subbing into an inactive slot, which is usually very difficult for scum
Out of these, the ones I believe the least are EggYolk, clonedcheese, and Universal. Anyone else is free to do this exercise if they wish.