Poor Approximations of Catgirls - Thread 1

what’s your opinion on it then, Min? What’s your opinion on my slot?

I dont feel like theres a cohesive direction today

2 Likes

Idk to me it looks like voting me, Moonwink or Marshal looks like the plan

TARGET VOTES VOTED BY
WindwardAway 3/11 Arctic (#5851); LASERpointer (#5769); Marluxion (#5340)
Wazza 5/10 alana (#6015); bladescape (#5963); Hippopablompoyeetus (#5578)
Mistyx 2/11 Millium (#6103); min (#5385)
Millium 1/11 Mistyx (#6100)
bladescape 1/11 nutella (#5100)
Marshal 1/10 WindwardAway (#6114)
BS4215 1/11 Marshal (#5244)
Hippopablompoyeetus 1/11 Wazza (#4633)
nutella 1/10 Illwei (#5519)
Squirrel2412 1/11 Wisdom (#4893)
Not Voting 5 BS4215; Kyubey; Moonwink; nightingale; Squirrel2412

All votes on marshal are bad

1 Like

/vote Mistyx @Nyarchmage

feelin pretty directionless

i may simply stop trying

I refuse to believe it’s objectively bad to vote Marshal
But nobody is selling me on why she’s town
Just parroting everyone else by saying vaguely that her macro is good and Vulgard wouldn’t vote a partner is far from what I’d call convincing reasons
Convince me what she’s done that benefits town. Give specific examples. Make me believe that you guys actually believe what you’re saying instead of handwaving, because you can absolutely misclear a wolf and set them up to endgame this way, and I don’t want that to happen with any slots, including but not limited to Marshal.

i most likely die without ever having had respectable and committed takes

ain’t that just the way

she pulled a ton of vul spew last night beyond the voting stuff that looked good for her on multiple fronts imo

i also just really townread her on a lot of micro post stuff idk

/vote Squirrel2412 @Nyarchmage

idr wanna go wind here i think

1 Like

Like seriously, if you guys continue to say voting Marshal is bad because Vulgard’s spew makes her town, it isn’t a stronger argument than how I’m saying I think she’s spewed wolf from Vulgard. It’s just two opposite interpretations meaning that it actually isn’t crystal clear.

If you’re going to argue back with a subjective interpretation and tell me my read is bad and wrong without giving examples, then vote me and I’ll thunderdome Marshal.

I’m not even completely set on locking marshal as a wolf but the arguments toward her being town have not been good arguments.

What’s the current case against Squirrel?
Last I left off, I said he was one of my townleans, but I ISO’d him now instead of going to sleep and there are a couple things I’m a little sketched out by

On the other hand there are some things that I think point away from him being a wolf but I need to give it more thought

1 Like

i thought his post on wazza was wolfy yesterday and he’s been basically coasting through the poe without doing much

1 Like

Which post was it? I’ll take a look if you know roughly where it was

1 Like

Also idr how much I said about Vulgard’s vote on Squirrel but there was a brief vote on Squirrel kinda early in the day and then it got moved, and never went back to Squirrel even when Squirrel was being wagoned against Arete, whom Vulgard claimed to townread

So spew looks bad for Squirrel but I wanna make sure that’s actually a correct interpretation

1 Like

That’s a heck of a lot of preflipping for an early post

TARGET VOTES VOTED BY
WindwardAway 3/11 Arctic (#5851); LASERpointer (#5769); Marluxion (#5340)
Wazza 5/10 alana (#6015); bladescape (#5963); Hippopablompoyeetus (#5578)
Mistyx 3/11 Illwei (#6141); Millium (#6103); min (#5385)
Squirrel2412 2/11 Mistyx (#6146); Wisdom (#4893)
bladescape 1/11 nutella (#5100)
Hippopablompoyeetus 1/11 Wazza (#4633)
BS4215 1/11 Marshal (#5244)
Marshal 1/10 WindwardAway (#6114)
Not Voting 5 BS4215; Kyubey; Moonwink; nightingale; Squirrel2412